The Reserve at Holy Cross property was once owned by the Congregation of Holy Cross (religious order of the Roman Catholic Church) as a retreat for priests studying at Holy Cross College of Washington, DC. As shownin this 1981 form for the Maryland Historical Trust, Holy Cross contained a lodge, dining hall, workshops and chapel. Stones from nearby historical structures (Deer Park Hotel and Hoyes Catholic Church, both of Garrett County) were used in parts of the construction. Structures were designed and built by "Holy Cross Priests and Brothers" during the 1930's.